If the south had won the civil war

Lee, with help from stuart, won at gettysburg and carried the south to victory in the war. At the outbreak of the war, the union had a population of 22 million people, while the south had a population of nine million, of which 45 percent were slaves, according to the civil war trust. What would have happened if the south won the us war. Race relations today in the old south, in rural areas and cities such as charleston. What if instead of a southern defeat, the confederates won the civil war. Some novels based on this premise if the south had won the civil war, by mackinlay kantor dixie victorious. Using alternate history, that is a question i am to theorize about. Slavery of course would be long gone, for economic reasons. What would this country be like if the south had won the. The author mackinlay kantor wrote a book, if the south had won the civil war, which was published in 1960.

A few of the most significant effects would be the changes of southern territory, changes economically, and. First, had the confederacy won the civil war, slavery would have undoubtedly continued in the south. Besides, if the south had won the civil war, who knows. It means that something so small and so insignificannot. The people of the confederacy were very concerned about two things. If the south had won the civil war, slavery could have. Family and nation in civil war virginia and the concise historical atlas of the u.

How would america be besides the obvious implications this event had on american history, the civil war is a bastion of what if type of thinking. What would america be like if the south had won the civil. If the south had won the civil war by mackinlay kantor. Due to irreconcilable differences between north and south over the issues of states rights and slavery, the american civil war erupted on apr. If the south had won the civil war is a 1961 alternate history book by mackinlay kantor, a writer who also wrote several novels about the american civil war as. If the south had won the civil war by kantor, mackinlay, 1904publication date 2001 topics united states history civil war, 18611865 fiction. If the american civil war had ended other than it didor if the federal government and the northern states decided to pursue a negotiated separation from the southresidents of the confederate.

If the south had won the civil war free pdf, doc, fb3, rtf. What if the south had won the war between the states. So, the question is, how long would the confederate states of america lasted had it won independen. He is the author of titles such as why confederates fought. I personally believe the south would go back to britain for the strong trade, and once again become their. If the south had won the civil war, slavery could have lasted until. The first seven southern states seceded from the union and formed the confederate states of america in february of 1861. If the outcome of the civil war was different and the south had won the war, there would be a countless number of changes in history. If the south had won the civil war is a 1961 alternate history book by mackinlay kantor, a writer who also wrote several novels about the american civil war as it actually happened. As the battle of gettysburgs 150th anniversary approaches, its hard to resist asking, what if the union had lost that fight, and the south eventually won the war. Goodreads members who liked if the south had won the ci.

Humpday won a special jury prize at the sundance film festival, helped spark the mumblecore film movement, and catapulted shelton to the top of any list of hot indie directors. It offers a look at churchills lively imagination at work, as well as a few glimpses of his views on race, war, and international politics as the storm. The union had a larger population and larger stocks of war gear than the confederacy. So just suppose that abraham lincoln had let the south go. Once upon a time, in an alternate reality, the south successfully seceded and slavery was still legal in parts of america.

Jim stempel is the author of numerous articles and eight books on american history, spirituality, and warfare. If the south had won the war between the states, otherwise known as the civil war, a myriad of incomprehensible changes to world history would have been made. Mackinlay kantor, pulitzer pricewinning author and master storyteller, shows us how the south could have won the civil war. Mcclellan president, and he would have bowed to the democratic partys peace faction and opened negotiations with the confederates. Books similar to if the south had won the civil war.

Longcore how different would the world be today if the confederate states of america csa had won. The essay is a playful study of a civil war counterfactual. It generated such a response that it was published in 1961 as a book. It immediately inspired a deluge of letters and telegrams from astonished readers and became an american classic overnight. We ought to know by now that the killing and destruction of wars tend to intensify hatreds, and theyre bound to play out, often in hideous ways that can be impossible even for. If the south had won the civil war mackinlay kantor the confederate states of america. If the south had won the war of northern agression or civil war, where might our two countries be today. If the south had won the civil war takes these whatifs and goes beyond the civil war to ask. If the confederacy had won, slavery would have continued in the. Use features like bookmarks, note taking and highlighting while reading if the north had won the civil war.

We will never really know what would have happened to the csa had the won the civil war and retained their independence. Written and directed by kevin willmott, it takes the form of a mock. The day the south nearly won the civil war, and his most recent, american hannibal. This of coarse comes from the chaos theory or what i have come to know it as the butterfly effect. If the south had won the civil war by mackinlay kantor has reunification comes later. If the south had won the civil war mackinlay kantor dixie victorious. The american civil war was the most devastating event in united states history. The extraordinary account of revolutionary war hero daniel morgan at the battle of cowpens. The western states would have joined the usa as ther. If the south had won the civil war originally appeared in look magazine nearly half a century ago. Here he sat down with all about history to discuss what might have happened had the southern states had won the american civil war. It was a speech of lincolns to this effect that sealed his assassination. The kkk whose originals were members of the democratic party might never have donned white robes and hoods. After the war, northerners didnt want to remember why they had fought, or at least the part about freeing the slaves.

The war in 1864 is being fought in virginia, said ian isherwood, assistant director of the civil war institute in gettysburg, pa. It was never the goal of the south to take over the north. What if the south won the civil war the flap of a butterflys wings can cause a typhoon half way around the world. If the south won the civil war, the world would look much different today because the usa would not have become a major world power. More recently, harry turtledove has published several series of novels, called the the southern victory or timeline191 series, detailing the fighting of both world wars on the american continent, rather than the european continent, as a. Published in book form soon after, kantors masterpiece has been unavailable for a decade. Here are some ways i think would events would have evolved.

There will be no coercion of the southern states by the people of the north. It immediately inspired a deluge of letters and telegrams from astonished readers, and became an american classic overnight. It changed the entire fate of the nation, and created the america we know today. If the civil war had a different ending the national. What would have happened if the south had won the civil. Frey professor of southern studies at louisiana state university. An alternate history kindle edition by heller, andrew j download it once and read it on your kindle device, pc, phones or tablets. Find books like if the south had won the civil war from the worlds largest community of readers. How would our country be different if the south had won. The confederate states of america tells the story of what might have happened had the south won the civil war. If the south had won the civil war, slavery could have lasted until the 20th century aaron sheehandean is the fred c. It was originally published in the november 22, 1960, issue of look magazine. Abraham lincoln had once stated that the conflict would not only determine the future of the united states but the very future of mankind.

The new project from the game of thrones creators could. Northern voters, dispirited by the stalemate, would have elected george b. Significantly, william tecumseh sherman won the war for the north by employing precisely the strategy that stonewall jackson had tried but failed to get the south to follow. If the south had won the civil war mackinlay kantor. If the south had won the us civil war, would we still be. A recent run of important historical studies have set themselves against the view of the antebellum south as.

If the south had won the civil war essay 338 words. Because rumblings about secession periodically resurface in various parts of the south, its tempting to ask, what if the south had won the civil war. It is hard to determine what would have happened if the south had won the civil war. Some argue that the confederates could have won if they had held atlanta, mobile, ala. Here is my version of how history might have transpired. Even before the civil war, the slave south and the free north werent so unconnected. We will travel back in time on this episode and discuss the different possibilities of what might have.